Politics
California Democrats Push to Restore Racial Preferences in Public Schools

Clear Facts
- California lawmakers passed a measure on a party-line vote that would repeal Proposition 209 protections for K-12 public education if voters approve it in 2028.
- Proposition 209, passed by voters in 1996, currently prohibits state and local governments from discriminating on the basis of race, sex, or ethnicity in public employment, education, and contracting.
- The same voters rejected a full repeal attempt in 2020 by a 57-43 margin despite heavy spending by proponents.
California legislators are once again attempting to undo the will of the people. For decades they have sought to overturn Proposition 209, the 1996 initiative that bars government from granting preferential treatment based on race, sex, or ethnicity. Voters have consistently refused to hand them that power.
With California facing serious challenges in homelessness, wildfire management, and infrastructure, lawmakers continue to focus on identity-based policies instead. The latest effort targets the heart of Proposition 209 by removing its protections from kindergarten through twelfth grade.
The measure passed along strict party lines in August and will appear on the November 2028 ballot. This gives voters ample time to examine what is actually being proposed and decide accordingly.
Removing Proposition 209 from K-12 education would once again allow racial considerations in gifted and talented program admissions, a practice that was common before the initiative passed. The referendum leaves university admissions untouched because the Supreme Court has already ruled such discrimination unconstitutional at that level.
However, the proposal would eliminate Proposition 209 protections for other aspects of higher education including financial aid, grading, housing, graduation standards, and institutional funding.
“Of course, universities have long taken the ability to pay into account in providing financial aid, and rightly so. Adding race on top of that serves no purpose except to benefit the sons and daughters of well-off parents who do have the ability to pay but who happen to be the right race.”
The sponsors, all members of the California Legislative Black Caucus, have made clear their intent to implement recommendations from the state’s reparations task force. Those recommendations include entirely free tuition for African Americans. The measure is part of the caucus’s “Road to Repair” package.
In 2020, voters rejected a full repeal effort despite endorsements from major Democratic figures and overwhelming financial advantage for the yes campaign. The public showed it supports the existing protections against racial discrimination.
Subsequent attempts have been designed to be more incremental, hoping to achieve through stealth what voters rejected outright. The current proposal is framed as a simple clarification, but its effects would be far-reaching.
Let us know what you think, please share your thoughts in the comments below.